Blaming Social Media Or Understanding Psychology Behind: Debate On Youth Well-Being

s we navigate the impact of social media on mental health and education, it's essential to consider the different perspectives. Some argue that social media has many drawbacks, including a negative impact on mental health and stress for parents.

Some countries are even considering banning it. However, young people have found value in using social media for learning, sharing, and entertainment. The question remains: Should restrictions be placed on young people's social media use? 

As per the article "Let's Stop Shaming Teens About Social Media Use", no concrete evidence supports the notion that social media is responsible for adverse outcomes among young people.

The article cites studies suggesting no direct correlation between social media use and negative effects on youths.

2022 meta-analysis, led by Jeffrey Hancock and involving 226 studies with 275,728 participants, found the overall association between social media and well-being statistically indistinguishable from zero. 

In simpler terms, there was no concrete evidence supporting a direct link between social media use and compromised mental health.

Examining longitudinal studies, such as the analysis of 1,700 adolescents in 2019, challenges the assumption that social media directly leads to depression. While depressed adolescent girls tended to use more social media, heavier social media users did not necessarily become depressed. 

Similarly, a study conducted by Madeline George, tracking over 2,000 adolescents, revealed a disconnection between perceived negative impacts of digital technology and actual impairment.

Angela Yuson Lee's research sheds light on a nuanced perspective, emphasizing the role of mindset in social media's impact on mental health.

While people who viewed social media as a tool they could leverage to pursue personally meaningful activities (i.e., a high-agency, positive mindset) had stronger social relationships and less psychological distress, people who saw social media as a harmful dependency (i.e., a low-agency, negative mindset) experienced more depression, stress, and anxiety. In addition, social media mindsets were associated with the ways that people interpreted the time they spent on social media and how they used it.

Positive attitudes about social media consistently correlate with greater well-being, suggesting that an individual's perception and agency in navigating these platforms play a pivotal role.

Many young people turn to social media to find information about mental health, particularly when they are struggling. In a survey of 1,300 adolescents, 90 per cent of those with depressive symptoms reported seeking online resources for mental health information, compared to 48 per cent of those without symptoms. 

Additionally, a meta-analysis of over 50 studies has demonstrated that evidence-based programs for school-aged children can significantly reduce cyberbullying and victimization.

Furthermore, small pilot studies suggest that using phones to provide social support can improve playground interactions for both autistic children and their neurotypical peers.

Instead of rushing to implement restrictions on social media, consider teaching children that such platforms are tools over which they have control. 

What is the way out? How can we encourage safe use instead of banning social media 

-Teaching children about self-efficacy can lead to better self-regulation. 

-Rather than instilling fear about strangers and predators, educating children about problematic behaviour from people they know in person and those they may encounter online is important.

 -Instead of blaming technology for problems, teaching kids to analyze their sources and transform information into knowledge critically is crucial. 

-Misinformation and data illiteracy pose significant threats to society today, and schools have a unique chance and responsibility to shape our future in this area. 

Above all, it is essential to model the behaviour we want to see in our kids. 

We should be responsible when using our phones and social media, think critically about media consumption, and thoughtfully engage with students and their devices.

As a parent or educator, it's natural to worry about the impact of social media on children. However, the adverse effects are often magnified when kids feel isolated and don't have a support system to turn to.

Building a solid relationship with your child and setting reasonable limits on screen time can go a long way in mitigating these concerns. Instead of bombarding them with questions, try to create an open and supportive environment where they feel comfortable sharing their problems.

It's important to remember that today's kids were born into a world where social media is ubiquitous.

As educators and parents, we must approach social media use among young people with open communication rather than conflict. We must question the narratives we hear about social media and digital technology rather than simply accepting them at face value.

Restricting access to these tools is not a viable solution, as young people are enthusiastic adopters of new technologies. At the same time, we need to be mindful of the potential negative impacts of social media and work to support students who may be struggling with its effects.

A nuanced approach to this issue can bridge the gap between generations and provide meaningful support to young people.

‍